FPL DefCon Tracker: Who Actually Hits the Threshold — and Why
Open full image ↗
Blog/analytics

FPL DefCon Tracker: Who Actually Hits the Threshold — and Why

DefCon isn't a measure of how good a defender is — it's a measure of how much defending his team does. The per-90 leaders so far this season, and the tactical reasons behind every number.

FPL Oracle6 September 202613 min read
Share

A few weeks into the defensive contributions era and most managers are still picking DefCon players the wrong way round — scanning a per-90 leaderboard, buying whoever is top, and wondering why the points don't arrive. The numbers on those leaderboards are real. What's missing is the reason behind them.

Because DefCon isn't really a measure of how good a defender is. It's a measure of how much defending his team actually does — and that is a function of tactics, game state and role, not ability. Get that idea straight and the whole table reads differently. Here's the current leaderboard, and more importantly, why it looks the way it does.

Want this for your own squad? The FPL DefCon Tracker checks every defender, midfielder and forward in your team against their threshold in one go — per 90, margin and minutes risk. Enter your FPL ID or manager name; no account needed. The tables below are a snapshot — the tracker updates every gameweek.

The DefCon Thresholds, and Why They Change by Position

Two points are awarded when a player reaches a threshold of completed defensive actions in a single match. The threshold and the qualifying actions differ by position:

PositionThresholdWhat counts
Defenders10Clearances, blocks, interceptions, tackles
Midfielders12Clearances, blocks, interceptions, tackles and ball recoveries
Forwards12Clearances, blocks, interceptions, tackles and ball recoveries
Goalkeepers—Not eligible

That second column is the detail people miss most. Ball recoveries do not count for defenders. A centre-back with a big recovery number is no closer to his threshold for it. For midfielders they do count, and for many of them recoveries are the bulk of the total — which is why the midfield threshold is 12 rather than 10 and still harder to hit.

For the full rules rather than the numbers, see our plain-English explainer on how DefCon works.

Why João Pedro and Bruno Fernandes Will Never Hit It

Start with the players managers keep asking about, because they own them:

PlayerPosOwnedPer 90Short by
HaalandFWD73.9%4.0−8.0
João PedroFWD64.4%2.3−9.8
B. FernandesMID38.3%5.8−6.2
SzoboszlaiMID32.3%8.4−3.6
GabrielDEF22.7%8.2−1.8
MbeumoMID20.4%5.2−6.8
VirgilDEF16.2%9.6−0.4

None of these are bad footballers and none of them are bad picks. They're just employed to do the opposite of what DefCon rewards.

Bruno Fernandes is a number ten. His job is to receive the ball in the final third and create — and every minute United spend on the ball is a minute he isn't making an interception. Same story for Mbeumo and Szoboszlai. Their teams want the ball, and defensive actions only happen when you don't have it.

Virgil is the one exception creeping in: at 9.6 he's only just short, because Liverpool press harder than the other possession sides. He's a borderline case who gets it in busier games, not a write-off.

The clearest case is Gabriel. He's an excellent defender at a dominant team, and Arsenal's expected goals conceded is 0.71 per 90 — the lowest in the league by a distance. There is nothing for him to clear, block or intercept. His teammate White sits at just 5.1 per 90 and still has 21 points, because Arsenal defenders are paid in clean sheets, not defensive actions.

The rule to take away: at elite possession sides, DefCon is structurally unavailable. Don't buy an Arsenal or Man City defender hoping for it, and don't be disappointed when it doesn't come — you're buying a clean sheet machine and that's a perfectly good thing to buy.

But "Bad Team = More DefCon" Is Wrong Too

Here's where the obvious next step trips people up. If elite teams don't defend, surely the worst teams — permanently under siege — must rack up DefCons? The data says no, and this is the most useful thing on this page.

TeamAvg DefCon / 90xGC / 90Clean sheets
Brentford9.751.252
Everton9.041.333
Liverpool8.581.233
Crystal Palace8.521.911
Leeds8.431.234
Ipswich Town8.281.830
Newcastle8.171.851
Man City6.801.502
Aston Villa6.371.852
Arsenal6.260.713
Brighton5.811.853

The sides conceding the most expected goals are all over this table. Palace and Ipswich post decent numbers, but Aston Villa and Brighton — conceding just as much — sit at the very bottom of the league. Meanwhile the top four, Brentford, Everton, Liverpool and Leeds, all concede among the fewest chances of anyone. Across the league the correlation between how much a team concedes and how many DefCons it racks up is effectively zero.

Which makes sense once you picture it. A team being genuinely overrun isn't making completed defensive actions — it's being passed through. Bodies are out of position, the ball goes past them, and the sequence ends in a shot rather than a tackle. Getting battered doesn't fill your stat sheet; it just concedes goals.

What actually generates DefCon is aggressive, organised ball-winning. Brentford, Everton and Leeds press hard, win possession back high, and get through enormous volumes of tackles, interceptions and recoveries — while conceding few chances, because winning the ball back early is also good defending. That's why five of the twenty players in the two top-ten tables below play for Brentford or Leeds alone.

The Three Team Archetypes

Every side falls into one of three buckets, and it tells you exactly what you're buying:

ArchetypeExampleDefConClean sheetsVerdict
Elite controlArsenal, Man CityVery lowExcellentBuy for clean sheets only
Aggressive presserBrentford, Everton, LeedsVery highDecentThe sweet spot
OverrunAston Villa, BrightonLowUnreliableAvoid — worst of both

The middle row is where the value is, and it's the row most managers don't know exists. They're picking between "premium defender at a good team" and "cheap defender at a bad team", when the actual answer this season is "cheap defender at a well-drilled pressing team" — you get the defensive actions and a realistic clean sheet chance from the same £4.5m slot.

DefCon Per 90: Top Defenders This Season

Filtered to 180+ minutes, because a per-90 from a single appearance is noise. The margin column is what matters — how far the rate sits above the 10 he needs.

PlayerTeamPer 90vs 10PriceOwnedCS
MendyHull City14.1+4.1£4.1m6.2%2
PinnockCoventry City14.0+4.0£4.5m0.1%1
FofanaChelsea13.6+3.6£5.0m0.2%0
SchusterBrentford13.5+3.5£4.5m0.4%1
EganHull City12.2+2.2£4.1m7.0%3
MukieleSunderland12.0+2.0£5.4m1.9%1
BotmanNewcastle11.8+1.8£5.0m0.7%1
LacroixChelsea11.6+1.6£5.9m6.7%0
MuharemovićLeeds11.6+1.6£5.0m4.4%2
AffengruberFulham11.5+1.5£4.5m0.2%1

Egan is the one to learn from. Early in the season he led every defender at 17.0 per 90; he's now at 12.2. Still comfortably clear, still £4.1m and 7% owned, with three clean sheets — but the rate has dropped by nearly five actions a game. That's exactly what his profile predicted: 50 of his 59 actions are clearances, blocks and interceptions and only 9 are tackles. A deep-block total built on Hull defending their box compresses as soon as the games get less frantic.

Mendy and Pinnock top the table, but both on under 300 minutes, and Mendy is projected for 65 minutes next time out. Treat their rates as promising rather than proven.

The pressing sides tell a different story. Brentford are still the best DefCon team in the league, but the name doing it has changed: Schuster has taken over at 13.5 while Ajer has settled exactly on the line at 10.0. Over at Leeds, Justin has slipped to 8.8. The lesson is that the system repeats, but the player it runs through can rotate — so check the current numbers before you commit a transfer.

DefCon Per 90: Top Midfielders This Season

PlayerTeamPer 90vs 12PriceOwnedPts
BentancurSpurs14.6+2.6£5.5m0.2%15
PalaciosIpswich Town14.4+2.4£5.0m0.1%11
MainooMan Utd14.2+2.2£5.5m1.5%22
CharlesFulham13.7+1.7£5.0m0.1%13
M. SangaréBrentford13.5+1.5£5.6m9.7%22
AdamsBournemouth13.2+1.2£5.0m0.3%12
JaneltBrentford12.8+0.8£5.0m2.5%28
GarnerEverton12.3+0.3£6.0m0.2%11
StachLeeds12.3+0.3£6.0m2.5%27
ScottBournemouth12.1+0.1£6.1m5.5%30

Only twelve of the 105 midfielders with 180+ minutes are averaging above the threshold — about one in nine, against one in five defenders. That's the central fact about DefCon in midfield: it's a much harder line to clear than the defenders' 10, and most of the names above sit less than two actions clear of it.

It's also a list of holding midfielders, which is the catch. The number six who wins the ball back is exactly the player who doesn't get near the box — so you're buying two points a week with almost no attacking ceiling behind it. That's a fine £5.0m squad filler and a poor use of a £6.0m slot, unless the player also offers something going forward.

The Double Threat: DefCon Plus Attacking Returns

The genuinely valuable players are the ones who clear the defensive line and still threaten the opposition box. There are very few:

PlayerPosDefCon / 90xGI / 90PtsOwned
ScottMID12.10.21305.5%
JaneltMID12.80.20282.5%
StachMID12.30.26272.5%
M. SangaréMID13.50.29229.7%
MukieleDEF12.00.26131.9%

Scott has the most points of the group at 30, built on 36 ball recoveries out of 60 actions — a role-driven profile. But he's now sitting right on the line at 12.1 and is flagged doubtful, projected for 44 minutes. Janelt is the cleaner pick today: 12.8 per 90, 28 points, £5.0m, 2.5% owned and projected for the full 90.

Mukiele is the defensive equivalent: an attacking right-back at Sunderland who clears the line at 12.0 and carries a real threat going forward, which is unusual because attacking full-backs normally sit too high to rack up defensive actions. Hall, who cleared the line early on, has slipped to 9.2.

The highest scorer of anyone clearing his threshold is actually Tarkowski — 43 points and 17.1% owned — but at 10.2 he's barely over the line, and his points come from clean sheets and a set-piece goal rather than steady attacking threat.

Why No Forward Is a DefCon Pick

Forwards need 12, the same as midfielders. The leading forwards with 180+ minutes, ranked:

PlayerPer 90vs 12Owned
Thomas-Asante10.7−1.30.8%
Kostoulas6.9−5.15.0%
Evanilson5.7−6.33.2%
Wissa5.5−6.518.7%
Calvert-Lewin4.7−7.324.6%
Haaland4.0−8.073.9%
João Pedro2.3−9.864.4%
Isak1.5−10.521.8%

Only one forward gets anywhere near it — Thomas-Asante at 10.7, and he's projected for 20 minutes. Nobody else reaches even 60% of the threshold. A striker's defensive work is pressing the centre-backs, which produces almost nothing that counts. Ignore DefCon entirely when picking forwards.

That gap has a direct consequence for your lineup: 21% of defenders clear their threshold and no forward does, which shifts the value of every defensive slot. We worked through what that does to formation across all eight legal shapes.

The Fixture Inversion Nobody Talks About

Here's the strategic wrinkle that catches experienced managers out. For twenty years the rule for defenders has been: buy the easy fixtures, because easy fixtures mean clean sheets.

DefCon partly inverts that. A CBI-heavy defender like Egan needs his team to be defending to accumulate anything — so a run of hard fixtures raises his DefCon floor while lowering his clean sheet chance. A run of easy fixtures does the opposite. The two point sources pull against each other.

Which is why the pressing sides matter so much. A Leeds or Brentford defender's numbers come from the system rather than from being under siege, so he doesn't need bad fixtures to deliver — you get the DefCon floor without sacrificing the clean sheet upside. When you're choosing between two cheap defenders, ask which one's total comes from his manager's tactics and which comes from his team being bad. Only the first one is reliable.

What Makes Up a DefCon Total, and Why the Split Matters

Two players can reach identical totals from completely different sources, and the sources have very different reliability:

PlayerPosTotalCBITacklesRecoveries
EganDEF5950912 (don't count)
ScottMID6015936

Egan's is 85% clearances, blocks and interceptions — opponent-driven, and it swings with the fixture. Scott's is 60% recoveries — role-driven, and it holds regardless of opponent. Same headline number, very different confidence — and you can already see it play out in Egan's rate falling from 17.0 to 12.2.

Every player profile on the site now shows this breakdown, with actions that don't count for that position marked as such.

The Trap: Per 90 Is a Rate, DefCon Points Are Per Match

One more way these tables mislead, including the ones above.

Two defenders both finish two matches with 34 actions and an identical 17.0 per 90. The first got 17 in each — threshold hit twice, 4 points. The second got 30 then 4 — hit once, 2 points. Same rate, half the return, because DefCon pays per match and doesn't care about your average.

The metric that answers this is hit rate: the percentage of matches in which a player actually reached his threshold. We don't publish it yet, because it needs a match-by-match record rather than season totals, and we're building that now. Until it's here, read every per-90 on this page as strong evidence rather than proof — and lean on the component split above, because a role-driven total is far more likely to repeat than a fixture-driven one.

Minutes Risk: The Number That Cancels Everything

A per-90 is worthless if the player isn't on the pitch for 90 minutes, and this is the most expensive mistake available on this page.

Mainoo is the clearest case. Third among all midfielders at 14.2 per 90, comfortably above the line — and flagged doubtful, projected for 58 minutes. Scott sits on the line and is projected for 44. Ndiaye is projected for 30. A player arriving with half an hour left cannot reach 12 defensive actions however intense his rate. The rate is real; the points aren't reachable.

A 10.0-per-90 defender who plays every minute is worth far more than a 14.0-per-90 midfielder who plays 35. Check the projected minutes on the profile before you spend the transfer.

Budget DefCon Picks at £4.5m and Under

This is where DefCon actually changes squads — two points a week from a £4.0m defender rewrites what the rest of your team can afford.

PlayerTeamPricePer 90vs 10Owned
MendyHull City£4.1m14.1+4.16.2%
PinnockCoventry City£4.5m14.0+4.00.1%
SchusterBrentford£4.5m13.5+3.50.4%
EganHull City£4.1m12.2+2.27.0%
ThomasCoventry City£4.0m10.7+0.78.6%
AjerBrentford£4.5m10.00.03.8%
DiopIpswich Town£4.0m9.0−1.012.5%

Diop is the cautionary one. Already 12.5% owned — very high for a £4.0m defender — and sitting below the line, at Ipswich, who are the overrun archetype: heavy xGC, zero clean sheets, mid-table DefCon. He's been bought as a DefCon source and the tactical profile doesn't support it. Thomas at Coventry costs the same, clears the line and has two clean sheets. Our budget enablers guide covers the wider cheap-defender question.

Cheap defenders who start delivering rise quickly, since a low-owned player needs far fewer net transfers to cross the threshold. How FPL price changes actually work explains why — and why beating one is rarely worth a hit.

How to Use This

  1. Buy DefCon in defence. Lower threshold, far bigger pool, cheaper slots. Ignore it entirely for forwards.
  2. Buy the pressing teams, not the bad teams. Brentford, Everton and Leeds give you defensive actions and clean sheets. Aston Villa and Brighton give you neither reliably.
  3. Ask where the total comes from. Recovery-heavy and tackle-heavy totals repeat. Clearance-heavy totals swing with the fixture list.
  4. Check projected minutes before the rate. A high per-90 on 30 minutes is a mirage.
  5. Don't expect DefCon from elite-possession defenders. Gabriel and White are bought for clean sheets — judge them on that.

Every profile in our player database now carries a DefCon section with the per-90, the margin against that player's threshold, and the full component breakdown. You can also compare two players side by side if you're stuck between them.

The quickest way to apply all five rules to your own team is the DefCon Tracker, which ranks your outfield players by how far they sit above or below their line and flags anyone whose minutes make the rate unreachable.

The Oracle Takeaway

DefCon is a tactics stat wearing a defending stat's clothes. The players farming it aren't the best defenders — they're the ones at clubs whose managers ask them to win the ball back constantly, which is why Brentford, Everton and Liverpool top the team table while Arsenal and Manchester City sit near the bottom — down there with struggling sides like Aston Villa and Brighton.

If you take three names: Egan at £4.1m is still the most proven cheap DefCon defender — 437 minutes and still +2.2 even after his rate came down; Thomas at £4.0m clears the line with two clean sheets; and Janelt at £5.0m is the best repeatable double threat, clearing the midfield line with 28 points and 90 projected minutes.

Run your own squad through Oracle's free tools to see which of your defenders are actually clearing the line — no account needed.

Who's your best DefCon pick so far — and has anyone in your squad surprised you? 👇

Check your own squad's DefCon

See which of your defenders and midfielders actually clear the DefCon line, per 90, with the margin and minutes risk.

Check my squad

Quick answers

How many DefCon does a defender need?

Defenders need 10 combined clearances, blocks, interceptions and tackles in a single match to earn 2 defensive contribution points. Ball recoveries do not count toward a defender's total.

How many DefCon does a midfielder need?

Midfielders need 12 defensive actions in a single match, and unlike defenders their ball recoveries do count alongside clearances, blocks, interceptions and tackles. Forwards use the same 12-action threshold.

Why doesn't Bruno Fernandes get DefCon points?

Because his role is the opposite of what DefCon rewards. As an attacking midfielder his job is to receive the ball in the final third and create chances, and defensive actions only happen when your team doesn't have the ball. He averages 5.8 per 90 against a threshold of 12. The same applies to Mbeumo, Szoboszlai and most attacking midfielders at possession-dominant clubs.

Why don't Arsenal and Man City defenders get DefCon points?

They dominate possession so completely that there is very little defending to do. Arsenal's expected goals conceded is around 0.71 per 90 — the lowest in the league by a distance — so Gabriel averages 8.2 defensive contributions per 90 and White just 5.1, both below the 10-action threshold. Defenders at elite possession sides are bought for clean sheets, not DefCon, and should be judged on that.

Do bad teams get more DefCon points?

No, and this is the most common misconception. Across the league there is effectively no link between how much a team concedes and how many DefCons it racks up. Aston Villa and Brighton concede among the most expected goals and post the lowest DefCon numbers in the league. What actually generates DefCon is aggressive, organised ball-winning: Brentford average 9.75 per 90 across defence and midfield, the highest of any club, while conceding few chances, because they press hard and win possession back high.

What is DefCon per 90 in FPL?

DefCon per 90 is a player's average number of qualifying defensive actions per 90 minutes played, used to compare players on different minute totals. Because DefCon points are awarded per match rather than per season, a high per-90 indicates likelihood rather than guaranteeing a player clears the threshold in any given game.

Who has the best DefCon per 90 in FPL 2026/27?

So far this season Mendy (14.1) and Pinnock (14.0) lead defenders on limited minutes, with Egan of Hull City the leading regular starter at 12.2 per 90 against a threshold of 10. Among midfielders, Bentancur of Spurs leads at 14.6 against a threshold of 12, followed by Palacios at 14.4 and Mainoo at 14.2. Figures are filtered to players with 180+ minutes; the free FPL DefCon Tracker has live numbers every gameweek.

Who are the best DefCon midfielders in FPL?

Twelve midfielders with 180+ minutes are averaging above the 12-action threshold, led by Bentancur (14.6), Palacios (14.4) and Mainoo (14.2). For FPL purposes the standout is Janelt of Brentford: 12.8 per 90, 28 points, £5.0m and projected for the full 90 minutes. Stach and Scott also clear the line while offering genuine attacking output.

Do forwards get DefCon points in FPL?

In theory yes, at the same 12-action threshold as midfielders, but in practice almost never. Only one forward with 180+ minutes gets close — Thomas-Asante at 10.7 per 90, and he is projected for just 20 minutes. Nobody else reaches 60% of the threshold: Kostoulas is at 6.9, Haaland 4.0 and Isak 1.5. A striker's defensive work is pressing centre-backs, which generates almost nothing that qualifies.

Do ball recoveries count for DefCon?

Only for midfielders and forwards. Defenders reach their 10-action threshold through clearances, blocks, interceptions and tackles only, so a defender's recovery count is irrelevant to his total. This is the most commonly misunderstood part of the rule.

What is DefCon hit rate and why does it matter more than per 90?

Hit rate is the percentage of matches in which a player actually reached his threshold. It matters more than per 90 because DefCon is all-or-nothing per match: two players can share an identical per-90 while one clears the line every week and the other alternates between huge and tiny games. The first is worth owning; the second is a gamble.

Should I buy defenders with easy or hard fixtures for DefCon?

It depends where their numbers come from, and DefCon partly inverts the usual rule. A clearance-heavy defender needs his team to be defending, so hard fixtures raise his DefCon floor while lowering his clean sheet chance. A defender at a pressing side like Leeds or Brentford gets his numbers from the system rather than from being under siege, so he delivers without needing bad fixtures — which is why those players are the better buy.

What are the cheapest good DefCon defenders?

Egan at £4.1m is the most proven, at 12.2 per 90 over 437 minutes and owned by 7% of managers. Mendy (£4.1m) and Pinnock (£4.5m) have higher rates on fewer minutes, Schuster at £4.5m is Brentford's current DefCon defender at 13.5, and Thomas at £4.0m clears the line at 10.7 with two clean sheets.

Do goalkeepers get defensive contribution points?

No. Goalkeepers are not eligible for defensive contribution points in FPL 2026/27, regardless of how many clearances or recoveries they record.

defcondefensive contributionsanalyticsdefenderssquad building

More from Oracle